From the recording The Atheists & the Donkey King

Lyrics

They were brought before me and they said
Enthusiastic for the one they followed
Opinions on this man were widespread
Some said a man from Galilee they hallowed

Some said a speaker good and true
Some said he worked with miracles in view
They all agreed he died upon a cross
But claimed he rose again though faced with loss

They said three days after he was dead
To them alive he did appear
They said the very words he said
And that his form was radiant and clear
He ate and drank with them once more
Then rose to heaven as they did implore

He taught the kingdom was at hand
To love forgive and do good in the land
The poor and oppressed would be blessed indeed
While seekers of worldly power would recede

They would not bow to the gods at all
In secret they would meet to heed the call
They chose to face the persecution pain
Their loyalty to him they would retain

Oh, Pliny, oh Pliny
What did they see?

I asked them if they were the Christian kind
Those who confessed I asked again
And threatened punishment to change their mind
But those who stayed I ordered slain
For stubbornness and obstinacy blind
Must meet with justice and the law's design

He taught the kingdom was at hand
To love forgive and do good in the land
The poor and oppressed would be blessed indeed
While seekers of worldly power would recede

They would not bow to the gods at all
In secret they would meet to heed the call
They chose to face the persecution pain
Their loyalty to him they would retain

Oh, Pliny, oh Pliny
What did they see?

Three days after his death, he appeared to them alive
He appeared to them alive
Not to others, but to them
They saw him, alive, and he told them to love each other

And they validated their claim with their life

They would not bow to the gods at all
In secret they would meet to heed the call
They chose to face the persecution pain
Their loyalty to him they would retain

Oh, Pliny, oh Pliny
What did they see?
What did they see?